779 Old Montauk Highway,
Montauk,
New York,
United States,
11954,
New York State
-
Near Kirk Park Beach
Great
8.8
8.8
/10
4.3
4.2
/5
Loved by Beach Plum Resort guests
Clean rooms
Great location
Refreshing pool
Private balconies
Attentive staff
Beautiful bathroom
"It was directly across from the beautiful beach."
Cheryle from United States
read full review
"Except for the price, this typical seaside motel, offers one bedroom suits, with a full kitchen and sitting/dining area, and a deck with lounge chairs and table with chairs overlooking the ocean."
Mirna
read full review
"Glass doors were thick enough to keep the sound from the traffic on the road down."
Nicole from United States
read full review
Rooms & Accommodations
Beach Plum Resort offers cedar-shingled cottages and rooms with full kitchens, fireplaces, and private decks. Each unit includes air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, a flat-screen TV, and a living area. Second-floor rooms in the main inn have views of the harbor. The decor features soft blues and whites, dark carpeting or wood laminate flooring, and light wood veneer furniture.
Dining Options
The onsite restaurant serves seasonal dishes with ocean views from a wall of windows and French doors. A local favorite is poached eggs over pan-seared cod fishcake with fresh salad greens. Nearby, Larsen's Fish Market offers takeaway seafood meals. Regular farm-to-table pop-up dinners feature guest chefs.
Leisure & Activities
Guests receive walk-on passes to private beaches: sandy Lucy Vincent and rocky Squibnocket. The resort has a heated pool, barbecue and picnic areas, and free summer yoga classes. Boat hire and mini golf are available at Puff 'n' Putt Family Fun Center, a 10-minute walk away. A shady grove path leads to Vineyard Sound for swimming.
Location & Access
The resort is on Martha's Vineyard's west side, 100 km from Long Island MacArthur Airport. Nearby landmarks include Second House Museum (0.5 km), Camp Hero State Park (1.5 km), and Ditch Plains Beach (3.5 km). Small local shops like Beetlebung offer unique gifts and clothing.
Guest Services
The property provides outdoor showers, fully-equipped kitchens, and direct beach access. Families can use barbecue grills and play areas. The complex consists of three two-story accommodation blocks and a main reception building. Some areas may have limited accessibility.
“In my opinion, it's a boutique-style escape that manages to feel both chic and family-friendly. What stands out to me is its access to a quieter stretch of the beach, plus the option for longer stays with kitchens in some rooms. A solid choice for those seeking a more intimate Montauk experience.”
Edward HayesEditor-in-Chief at Beachresort
View all
Pick the Room Type That Suits You
Choose from spacious beach suites, family rooms, or cosy couples’ retreats with perks like breakfast and free cancellation
One-Bedroom Bungalow
2 persons
1 King-size bed
Cottage
2 persons
1 King-size bed
Apartment Balcony
2 persons
2 Double beds
Two-Bedroom Apartment
2 persons
1 King-size bed
Click button to see more rooms
Show all rooms
Show all roomsLess
Check Prices & Room Availability
See what's available for your travel dates now!
Facilities
Enjoy comfortable stays and unforgettable experiences at our beach resorts
Facilities:
Perfect
9.1/10Review score
General
Non-smoking rooms
Free Wi-Fi
Parking
No pets allowed
Private beach
Sports & Fitness
Golf course
Guest Parking
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Services
Housekeeping
Spa & Leisure
Seasonal outdoor pool
Heated swimming pool
Beach access
Sun loungers
Garden area
BBQ facilities
Room features
Air conditioning
Sitting area
Patio
Terrace
Self-catering
Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
Media
Flat-screen TV
Room decor
Parquet floor
Show more
Location & Nearby Attractions
779 Old Montauk Highway,
Montauk,
New York,
United States,
11954,
New York State
Map view
779 Old Montauk Highway,
Montauk,
New York,
United States,
11954,
New York State
City landmarks
Park
Kirk Park Beach
4600 ft
Park
Camp Hero State Park
5300 ft
Landmark
Saint Therese of Lisieux Church
4700 ft
Park
Fort Pond Bay Park
1.7
mi
Store
Sunset Surf Shack
4400 ft
Park
Shadmoor State Park
1.7
mi
Landmark
Montauk Downs State Park
1.8
mi
Golf Course
Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course
1.8
mi
Park
Hither Woods Preserve
1.9
mi
Farm
Rita's Stable
2.0
mi
Landmark
Hither Hills
2.2
mi
Landmark
Fort Pond Bay
2.2
mi
Landmark
Ditch Plains Beach
2.3
mi
Park
Theodore Roosevelt County Park
2.6
mi
Landmark
Hither Hills West Overlook
2.9
mi
Landmark
Gosman's Dock
3.3
mi
Nearby
Museum
Second House Museum
1300 ft
Montauk
Lake Montauk
1000 ft
Restaurants
ALL DAY at Breakers
200 ft
769 Old Montauk Hwy
Surfside Inn
2100 ft
685 Old Montauk Hwy
Bex Waffles
2600 ft
650 Montauk Hwy
7-Eleven
4000 ft
653 Montauk Hwy
Harvest On Fort Pond
5100 ft
11 South Emery Street
Sel Rrose
3300 ft
4 S Elmwood Ave
Zum Schneider Montauk
3300 ft
4 South Elmwood Avenue
The Point
4900 ft
697 Montauk Hwy
The Point Bar & Grill
4800 ft
697 Montauk Hwy
Pizza Village
5200 ft
700 Montauk Hwy
Explore Montauk
Explore Montauk
Top Attractions
Activities
Dining
Entertainment
Lake Montauk
4 minutes walking
Lake Montauk offers serene views and water activities, perfect for fishing or kayaking in a picturesque setting.
Second House Museum
5 minutes walking
This historical museum showcases Montauk's heritage with exhibits in a charming 18th-century house.
Kirk Park Beach
17 minutes' walk
Kirk Park Beach features soft sand and family-friendly facilities, ideal for sunbathing and swimming.
Sunset Surf Shack
15 minutes' walk
A vibrant surf shop offering rentals and lessons, plus a great spot for surf enthusiasts to connect.
Kayaking on Lake Montauk
4 minutes walking
Kayaking provides an adventurous way to experience Lake Montauk, with rentals available onsite the waterfront.
Hiking at Shadmoor State Park
30 minutes' walk
Shadmoor State Park features scenic trails through stunning coastal views, great for both hiking and picnicking.
Yoga Classes
15 minutes walking
Local studios offer relaxing yoga sessions that cater to various skill levels, a perfect wind-down after a day of activities.
ALL DAY at Breakers
1 minute walking
A casual eatery known for its breakfast all day, delicious omelets, and beachfront views, making it a local favorite.
Harvest On Fort Pond
19 minutes' walk
This farm-to-table restaurant serves fresh seafood and seasonal dishes in a warm atmosphere with outdoor seating.
Surfside Inn
8 minutes walking
Rustic ambiance with a menu featuring American cuisine and local catches, ideal for families and groups.
The Surf Lodge
10 minutes' drive
A lively venue with seasonal live music, offering a beachy vibe and stunning sunsets over the marina.
Montauk Movie Theater
10 minutes' drive
This charming local theater offers a mix of blockbuster films and indie features, perfect for families and movie lovers.
Getting around beach destinations
City Centre
Montauk9 min
·
2300 ft
Airports
Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)160 min
·
66.1
mi
Tweed-New Haven Airport (HVN)251 min
·
103.7
mi
Want Access to Special Advance Rates?
Grab limited-time exclusive prices now!
Check Rates
Property information and rules
Check-in
from 16:00-19:00
Check-out
until 11 am
Guest Parking
Public parking is possible on site for free.
Internet
Wireless internet is available in for free.
Children & extra beds
There are no cots provided in a room.
Pets
Pets are not allowed.
Number of rooms:
30
Guest Ratings & Coastal Resort Reviews
See What Past Guests Had to Say About Their Stay
Review score
Based on 67 verified reviews
8.8/10
Great
96%
Recommend
Breakfast
8.7/10
Cleanliness
9.2/10
Comfort
9.2/10
Facilities
9.1/10
Free Wi-Fi
8.1/10
Location
9.4/10
Paid Wi-Fi
10.0/10
Staff
9.4/10
Value for money
8.7/10
Pros
Beach access
Well-equipped kitchen
Comfortable sofa bed
Cons
Thin walls
Noisy neighbors
Busy street
Guest reviews
based on 172 reviews
8.8/10
No reviews yet on our siteUnfortunately, our guests have not yet left any reviews for this hotel, but you can read reviews from Booking.com.
Atlantic Beach Hotel Newport
Montauk Oceanside Suites
The White Sands Resort And Spa
Seabonay Oceanfront Motel
Ocean Mist Hotel
Hero Beach Club
Ocean Colony Beach & Tennis Club
Edgewater Beach Resort
Carolina Grande
Beach Colony Motel
Blue Mountain Resort Village Suites
Hut At Hole Farm Alderbury Holiday Home Web
Hotel Hotel La Source
